About the famous "What was inside the wreakage" mystery.
When I first saw this episode, and we see Apollo and Starbuck's reactions to the interior of the wreck, I started to get the impression that maybe it was the wreakage of the Battlestar Pegasus. But, for some reason, I never once thought that Commander Cain's body was in the wreck. I always thought for some reason that it was a large version of the insignia of the Battlestar Pegasus. I was also dissapointed when we never find out what was in that wreakage.
Oh yeah, the endding of part one really, and I mean REALLY creeped me out when I first saw it. I was all focused on Baltar's surrender and the mystery of Count Iblis, then, suddenly, cue the creepy music and a sudden reminder of The Ship of Lights with the dreaded "To Be Continued" title. There was just something about it that creeped me out badly.
EDIT: The scene creeps me out, and yet I use it as my avatar...