I would have to cast my vote for the PS2 system as well. When the new BSG game came out, I didn't own a game system and I had to make a choice. I asked friends and nobody could really give me a comparison - they either owned one or the other and were happy with their choices. Another factor that made me pick the PS2 at the time was cost - the PS2 was only 179.00 at the time and the X-Box was 200.00. I did hear that the X-Box was just dropped in price to 149.00.
In the end, you kind of just have to go with one or the other - I doubt that you will regret buying either system
Good luck,
Bryan
________
Recall Wellbutrin