First, Craig, let me welcome you to CF. We've got a great group of people here who are a lot of fun, and know a lot about a bunch of different things.
Just watch out for the beavers trying to sell yellow kool-aid.......
However, not long ago the decision was made to focus our BSG discussions on the original series. After a long, tempestous period where we tried to be all things to all people, it was decided that we would instead support our first love - the original Battlestar Galactica.
The main focus of this site is art - the learning, practicing and perfection of the art of Battlestar Galactica. In that discussion we welcome art from almost any inspiration, even "GINO" (just keep in mind we're a family site), but other discussions regarding BSG are limited to the 1978 universe - and a continuation of that universe.
The discussion you propose here is beyond that restriction.
If you want to nitpick, or re-write, or build on the original episodes, head over to the "Last Battlestar-Galactica" forum. It's all there, and we'd welcome you to join in those exchanges.
Happy New Yahren, and, again, welcome to CF.
I am
Dawg