Lara |
March 11th, 2005 09:49 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by BRG
Thanks for the info Rowan. :)
I'm not suprised I havn't heard of the SCA, it appears to be a mainly North American orginisation. And although there is a Scotish society- The Shire of Harpelstane , it is based in Lothian and Fife in the East of Scotland. Edinburgh and St Andrews are a good 60-70 miles from my Ayrshire home! It may not sound far to Americans & Canadians, but it's the other side of the country for BRG!
A guy I work with is into this sort of thing. He does all that 'Braveheart' battle reinactment carry on, you know, the dress up as Scots & Engilsh from Bannockburn or Culloden and pretend too hack each other to bits. Then round the day off by having a sing-song and getting pissed!
When I was a boy, we went to a 'Tournament' when we were on holiday in Northumberland. They had joust & sword fights in full battle armour, and it was really cool. Although they also had a RAF rescue helicopter giving a display, it sort of broke the fantasy! :D
BRG
|
Australia imported the SCA from the Americans about 20 years ago, via the SF&F connection. It has its greatest appeal to colonials (excuse the pun) who have no direct medieval history of their own to reenact.
It has been compared to live role playing (which it is not) and to living history (also which it is not)
For places like Britain and Europe, the SCA ios only present as a result of US bases, and the rest of the native population tend to get involved with smaller authenticity and living history groups based on real and usually local history instead of joining a recreated Kingdom . The main difference is these other groups do mostly demonstartions and performances, whereas the SCA does it for their own amusement and holds events that are closed to the public vs being paid public performance.
I won't get into the authenticity vs recreationism debate, but I will say each side has things to offer, and not all things suit all people.
Personally I have played SCA at a high level for 20 yrs, but I have also belonged (long distance) to Regia Anglorum, which is an ultra authentic living history group based in Britain. It now has US offshoots from SCA people looking for authenticity in their Viking/ Norman AngloSaxon persuits, but there was not critical mass enough here to form a subgroup..
The sort of mixed military display you saw is quite common now, and often reflects the whole military history of a site. I like the authenticity of these displays, but I scratch my suspension of disbelief itch with the SCA: I have truly heard and seen things than transcend time, and history doesn't become more alive than that!!
Cheers,
Lara
|