PDA

View Full Version : Mini Feedback - Something Very Very Odd


Muffit
December 9th, 2003, 12:22 PM
Hi all! It was too painful for me to watch the mini, so I spent the night watching the original and wonderful DVDs. However, that doesn't mean I forgot what was going on - so every few minutes or so, I would check the SciFi site for feedback - good way to watch without actually watching!

And this is what was very very odd. For the first 100 posts or so, and during the first showing until about the first half of the second showing, the feedback on SciFi was /tremendously/ negative! Not just ho-hum, but downright hated the thing. There were only a few positives, and they were drowned by the negatives.

Then, suddenly, well after the end of the first showing and nearing the end of the second, the SciFi posts turned /decidedly/ positive - with zero negatives! And instead of being gradual, they all hit at once.

Not until much later did the tally finally change back somewhat - to what looks more like 50-50.

When you are watching a board like I was, this looks /really really/ odd. Yes, you expect the teeter totter to shift back and forth a bit, but nothing like this, not all of a sudden. The only other time I saw something like this happen was when we had a concerted effort by pro-mini folks to flood the board with false posts.

I have a strong feeling we may never see the actual ratings for the show, or an actual percentage of viewer comments. That feeling is pretty overwhelming right now. Call me overreactive, but in life whenever things seem overly coincidental to be true, they usually aren't.

Well, I do hope we get authentic data after all. It will be interesting for sure.

Silly me,
Muffit
:muffit:

Starbuck
December 9th, 2003, 12:34 PM
Sciffy is probably deleting all the negative posts. They may have to hire someone full time for the next several days to do that though! :girl: :choco:

AlternityOrange
December 9th, 2003, 12:34 PM
Obviously the Sci-Fi Board is rigged, and has been for sometime. It can't be used as a barometer to judge viewer opinions. I've been going to many different disussion boards today, ones which the clones are not known to frequent, in order to try to get a better sampling of general people's opinions. Not scientific I know but it's about all we can do.

So far I'm seeing about 2 to 1 against the mini. Even those that liked it have been saying stuff like, "It was alright." I haven't come across too many non-clone glowing reviews.

The ratings will be out soon enough, they'll be spun but at least we'll know. But you're right Muffit, we'll never know the true reaction of "real" people. A small group of pathetic individuals will make certain of that.

BST
December 9th, 2003, 02:37 PM
Muffit and all,

Fear not. It's just another AOTCM - Attack of the CloneMaster. :D

For ratings info, please check the Nielsen site (below):

http://www.nielsenmedia.com/ratings/cable_programs.html


I think it's safe to say that this is one place where Teddyboy has absolutely no influence! :D

BST