For the Larson Supporters
For those "discussing" alternate universes that would
leave the original intact, you need to research your facts. Also there are some Larson supporters stating that since Ron Moore's script isn't a remake they don't have a problem with it. Well, per Ron Moore the Sci-fi Production of BSG is a REMAKE . Therefore Moore' BSG is not an alternate universe. Moore's BSG is meant to re-write the original, plain and simple. Ron has stated that he wants to go back to the beginning and tell the story from the start. That doesn't mean he wants to create an alternative new universe so Larson can have his own unharmed, it means he wants to over write Larson's creation. Since it's a remake Larson supporters should stand by what they've stated and start protesting Ron's non-canon remake because whether the mini is a success or not, it will over write Larson and there won't be any chance for any coninuation movie after that. Everyone needs to realize that the alternate universe "discussion" is as invalid as bsgbountyhunter's "sidestory" disscusion and in my opinion implemented for the same reasons. If you go ahead and waste your time discussing or believing in an alternate universe, then you're only helping Moore, CaptJames and his ilk. That's how Moore's crew likes to play, they "imagine and "pretend" with you all they want in order to neutralize and betray you. They have already did this to the rest of Galactica fandom during their so called joint letter writing campaign to preserve the original timeline. Even though virtually every Larson supporter would rather have Moore's vision and Larson's vision on separate timelines, the heart of the matter is they already lied and betrayed three different camps ( Singer/DeSanto supporters, Hatch supporters and the legit remake supporters) within the Galactica fandom. Who's to say that the Larson supporters won't be their next victims on the list? I hope that Larson fans read the Q & A with Ron Moore at bsg.com to have a better understanding of what this remake represents. http://www.battlestargalactica.com/d...ept2002qa.html Ron: It's precisely because I was a fan of the old show that I want to do a remake. I'd like to go back to the beginning and tell the story from the start because I think it's the best way to make a successful series and the way that opens up the most creative avenues to explore. Q: What advantages does the reimagining have over a continuation? Ron: "...my pitch was to remake the series. Did I think about doing a continuation? Sure, it was an obvious (and creatively valid) idea, but in all honesty it didn't interest me as a writer as much as the possibilities inherent in going back to the beginning and retelling the story from a fresh perspective." Q: Will this be more of a "remake" than a "re-imagining"? Will it easilly fit into the existing Galactica universe? Will fans be able to easilly accept the new version as an extension, if not continuation, of the original? Ron: I'm not sure of the semantic difference you're trying to make. It will follow the same basic plot as the original with most of the original characters, themes and settings. Q: ...WHY is this production being called a reimagining? Ron: Personally, I call it a remake. BTW Chris Larson says that the remake sucks |
O U C H !
|
Hey Scooter whats up? gotta PM you man, got something to share with you real soon.
Be around on CF during the weekend o.k.? KJ |
The 2 productions occupy 2 similar but entirely seperate stories realities.
Why is that such a hard concept to grsasp? Especially since G:80 has been considered some kind of bad dream/alternate reality since for as long as i can remember. There is absolutly no established cannon in either TOS or G:80 that proves that theory out, fans just accept it... So just accept this as no more relevant than G:80 This airing of this production will not cause your memories of the original to be altered. Universal will not be altering the footage of the original episodes to omit Dirk Benidict as starbuck. The same way 2 or 3 diffrent versions of count of monti cristo, robin hood or the ring can exist side by side on the video store shelf Multiple versions of galactica can exist as well. And like those folms peole will prefer one version over the other. If you want to see an actual for real rewriting of a franchise look to the StarWars films. They are actualy being altered from there original form to incorporate new themes and ideas. I's lucas' bebby and he can do it but that is a group of fans that has actualy had somthing taken away from them. |
Hito, what it comes down to is your lucky if you can make that mistake once. Galactica 1980 was so bad and felt so rushed, it also had the reasoning of the time slot so fans and TV industry types could easily discount it as a non-event.
Twenty five years later you can't make that mistake a second time, when this mini-series fails convential wisdom will be "two out of three seasons" this concept is just crap. Time, most Original series fans believe the best thing for the franchise is a mix of old and new...if it doesn't happen soon it'll be to late. |
Hito,
I confess i'm not very familiar with g80, but i do believe that, in g80, they never re-told the story from the begining, they never did sex changes, they never renamed key characters, they never changed one entire race's origins... That is to me reason enough to be unable to place g2003 in an "alternate reality". As for some Larson fans that recently returned to the boards, all i see is that they want revenge from whatever Hatch's fans did to them. nothing more. Like:"because of you we didn't get ours, so now you'll not get yours..." From that recent poll, i see that there are alot of Larson, Hatch, DeSanto and Moore's fans, but there are also alot of Galactica fans, and there's where i decided to stay. I'm tired of all this fighting between fans. |
Re: For the Larson Supporters
Quote:
|
Re: For the Larson Supporters
Quote:
After that, when the Singer/DeSanto production fell behind due to 9-1-1 and then later was cancelled and the reimagined mini-series was announced for Sci-Fi, my interest has waned considerably. This forum has really been the only outlet, other than a few (emphasis on few) bones thrown at the original fans by Dynamite comics and watching the original series on DVD... |
Re: For the Larson Supporters
Ever check out the VS?
|
All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:59 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.11, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content and Graphics ©2000-Present Colonial Fleets