I wouldn't really change the last scene though, because showing the image of the Apollo XI landing allowed the series to end on a broader hopeful note: They haven't found Earth yet, but they are moving in the right direction and it's something we can envision happening some day.
|
Hence the need for VS2.
(Shameless plug!) |
The more the better! :D
|
Okay, I hate to be a party pooper here, but if I might point out, radio and tv transmissions travel at the speed of light. With that said, the signal is now 36 lightyears out from earth, or out around Denebola, a KOV star about 36.180 lightyears out.
This was the only problem I had with the series, the implication that it was a concurrent time line, reinforced with the second battlestar galactica series. So I would have made two changes, first, when the first transmission is recieved, make it a news broadcast with date and year. During the episode, I would have other messages come in, copied by the bridge crew, ending with the "one small step for man." This gives the Galactica crew an idea on how far back the "lost colony" had fallen. Personally, I feel that this would have broadened the story line and given the show a better chance at surviving. |
There's one other little technicality about the transmission to note if we want to be completely realistic. TV audiences in 1969 did not see the images that we see in the episode because that was film shot that wasn't developed and aired until long after the astronauts returned to Earth. The TV audience at the time was watching network animated simulations as they heard the radio transmissions live (so that means one can argue that what the Galactica picked up was some "historic documentary" aired who knows how many yahrens after 1969!) :)
|
Well, the Network would never think in terms of that degree of realism, EP. And people want to "see" something. I noted that too, but I just put it down to the folks at ABC assuming that we the viewers were too slow to understand without pictures.
|
Naturally, that kind of realism wouldn't work because only TV history buffs would understand that. Sometimes what's "realistic" would make for lousy storytelling unless you had footnotes.
|
Quote:
This would have been a good closing shot: INTERIOR-CELESTRIAL DOME: Apollo and Starbuck exit the dome as the Apollo moon landing transmission is seen and heard on the monitor. Cut to a shot of space. Spiritual images of Ilia, Serina, Zac, and President Adar smiling are seen amonst the stars. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Should not something of a crisis along those lines, pitting Sire Uri and his gang of never do wells, form a good basis for an episode about the fleet's plight? This is also where a Count Iblis or Baltar-like infiltrator could again rear its/his ugly head to exploit divisions within the Colonials much as Korach and his followers exploited dissension to rebel against discipline during another famous Exodus? We have had foreshadowings of this in "Saga" and subsequent episodes. Why not bring it to a head at last and deal with it? As always; |
Quote:
Glad you agree. Ah, what should have been. |
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Quote:
|
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Quote:
I also like the closing shot that we saw at end of the episode. |
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
This has been an interesting read, old thread but i just found it ;)
I know this has been done before on another movie, I had this idea for long time that the transmission received should've or could've been perhaps Hitler opening the Olympics. (i think 70's TV mind set prevented that) and maybe amplified through space via gravitational lensing or accelerated through a white hole. I think it would've made more sense, I think, to have an older transmission. The other idea I had was no transmission received at all, instead, Galactica's scanners pick up a large gravitational anomoly on the planet the 3 base ships are hiding behind. They discover the USS Eldridge. (or is that to comical?) Cheers. Edit: umm, that last bit was an idea for one of my stories. |
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Quote:
My reasoning: 1. Yuri was a prominent politician and Serina was a reporter. Perhaps before the Holocaust She may have "done whatever it takes" for an interview, it happens in the real world all the time. 2. Yuri certainly wouldn't have been too faithful to Siress Yuri for this. 3. Yuri and Serina both escaped Caprica on the Rising Star, we know it was a hard ship to get onto (MOTRS), obviously Yuri bought his way on board, perhaps Serina blackmailed him to take her and his secret illegitimate kid too. 4. Serina KNEW what was going on in the elite class when Apollo was investigating the food shortage. She told Apollo he wouldn't like what he found there. Security at Yuri's door was good, too good to allow thirdclass refugees into that room to see what was going on. Serina obviously had ongoing contact with Yuri. 5. She refuses to tell who was his father, if its Yuri I dont blame her. 6. Boxey is a spoiled obnoxoius brat, a chip off the old block in some regards. Anyhow, I'm sure this idea will piss some people off. |
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Interesting idea.
I think most fans tend to think of Serina as being above that sort of behaviour though. Maybe it's just me, but the idea of her--or any female with two good eyes and a brain--with Uri gives me the heebie jeebies. However, we don't really learn much about her, only deduce characterization through what we're shown. And when a heroine dies so tragically, she becomes respectable and untouchable in most minds. And Boxey wasn't a spoiled, obnoxious brat, but a traumatized child. Hey, I wasn't particularly fond of the character either, but it certainly helped mold Apollo, keeping his character clearly defined and vastly different from Starbuck's. And the way those two men clicked despite those differences kept the show even more interesting, and for that I'm glad there was a Boxey. |
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Quote:
It has nothing to do with "70s TV mind set", whatever that means. It's simpky a matter of technology. |
olympic games
The Olympic games transmission was a major point of the Jodie Foster movie "Contact."
|
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Never saw it.
|
Re: olympic games
Quote:
|
Re: 17: The Hand Of God
Mmmmmmmmmmmmm.................
|
All times are GMT -7. The time now is 06:05 AM. |
Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.11, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content and Graphics ©2000-Present Colonial Fleets