"Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Please use this thread to discuss the story, "Matter of Honor".

BST

:)

Well, I just had the pleasure of reading this story.
I could envision this as a two-part ep.


Nice job, Eric!

:thumbsup:

Thank you very much, Pete! :salute: in return.

If you see this as a two-part episode though, that does make me wonder how many parts you're going to be viewing Episode #4 by our own Senmut. :)

:eek:

Umm, I think I hear the coffee pot a-beckoning!

:D

Seriously, there were too many action scenes to fit this into a 1-hour block. I might have to go back to review it but, I think a break point might have been possible during the first council meeting. Kudos to the treatment for Adama....Antipas had Adama right where Adama wanted him.

;)

Thanks! Sire Antipas is probably the one character I've created I felt that was most essential to address the complaint that Galactica too often had the Council members as buffoon type villains. Trying to come up with a formidable, serious adversary with youthful charisma was what I was looking for there. I keep thinking of Timothy Dalton in "The Lion In Winter" as the image of what Antipas would be.

Nicely written, and well paced. I really felt for Apollo when his quiet, romantic evening with Sheba was spoilled. At least they got back together for the end! :salute: :thumbsup:

Now we just have to watch out for that Councilor...

I'm definitely going to continued reading these!

Thanks, Raptor! Glad you enjoyed it. :salute:

I don't know about a two parter, but the story would've made for a really strong hour long episode.

Thanks! Yes, I envisioned it more as a low-key one hour type episode. It's not until we get to VS #4 ("Relics") that the budget-busting two-parters begin. :)

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

I am glad I got to read "Matter of Honor" I must say it was pretty good.

Infact I can't wait to read the next one! Thanks for creating them and for sharing them with us all.

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

EXCELLENT! :thumbsup: :salute:

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Much appreciated! I'll be making sure that more stories that have been finished get posted here soon.

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Um, yeah, just knock on the doorbell or ring the door when you're ready!

:eek:

Oh my, I'm so confoozed. :D

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

LOL, Episodes 9-12 are on their way to you!

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

I just read this, and i agree with Eric's comment that its a low key 1 part episode. but its very good,and i can find no flaws it.
this would very easily work as a filmed episode as is.

marvin

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Many thanks Punisher!

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

We write better than 90% of TV folks do!

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

I can't open any of the PDF files for these first few episodes. :(

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Vulpa II,

Sorry for the inconvenience. It appears that this is "fallout" from a server problem that we encountered, last week. I'll need to reload these files.

Thanks for letting us know.

:salute:

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

We we'll be whating . :salute:

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

And we'll be waiting too! :rotf:

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Yep that two . :duck::rotf::D

Re: "Matter of Honor" Discussion Thread
 

Like most of what EP writes...this is ure the superior of anything one might have seen....elsewhere. (ahem..cough...cough....)